News Photos
Search Advanced Sign in / Register fans
 
WORLD NEWS    
 

Advertisement

Agreement on climate change looks unlikely before U.N. talks
U.N. to extend the emissions-cutting targets of the 1997 Kyoto Protocol
By David Francis
The Christian Science Monitor
Page 9
2009-11-08 12:00 AM
+ Enlarge This image
Javier Solana, the European Council's foreign minister, left to right, U.S. President Barack Obama, Jose Manuel Barroso, president of the European Commission,and Fredrik Reinfeldt, prime minister of Sweden, walk from the Oval Office to the Cabinet Room during the U.S.-European Union summit at the White House in Washington, D.C. on Tuesday.
Bloomberg
The world is moving toward December climate change talks that have been described in some quarters as "pivotal." But a European Union agreement, signed last week, sheds light on how tenuous the prospects are for a comprehensive deal any time soon.

U.N.-sponsored talks are scheduled in Copenhagen, and it was initially hoped they would extend the emissions-cutting targets of the 1997 Kyoto Protocol. But Artur Runge-Metzger, head of the European delegation at a preliminary meeting in Barcelona for the Copenhagen negotiations, said Thursday that a deal was unlikely on schedule. "There is a lot of work still to be done," he told reporters.

Last week, European Union officials lauded their internal agreement - which determined that US$150 billion would be needed over the next decade to combat climate change - as evidence of a united front heading toward Copenhagen.

These officials claim the agreement will give them leverage in negotiations with China and the United States, both of which have been reluctant to name specific targets for emission reduction. House Democrats - over a threatened Republican boycott - are currently pushing a bill through committee that would cap U.S. emissions.

But the EU agreement is short on specifics, reflecting what critics say are fractures over which countries should shoulder the financial burden for helping poor nations shift to more sustainable energy sources.

These experts also claim that naming extremely ambitious goals, as preferred by European negotiators, is the wrong way to go about effecting climate change.

The agreement failed to specify which countries would contribute to the US$150 billion fund, and at what level. This was done to appease central and eastern European countries like Poland and Lithuania, which objected to initial plans to tie funding commitments to carbon-emission levels. In the past two decades, these countries have not had the money to create clean energy technologies or take carbon-emitting power plants offline.

Meanwhile, countries like Germany experienced a steep drop in carbon emissions after reunification in 1990, when Soviet-era heavy industries were shut down in the east and the former West Germany helped soften the blow.

"West Germany footed the bill for East Germany," says Kurt Volker, a scholar at the Center for Transatlantic Relations and a former U.S. ambassador to NATO. "No one has footed the bill for middle and eastern Europe. They don't have the government budgets right now to make drastic changes to their economies."

The same dilemma exists in the developing world. Energy-efficient technology is expensive. Developing nations are forced to rely on outdated technology, which, in turn, emits more greenhouse gases.

"Europe, in producing this [agreement], is ... not talking about ideas that bring in developing countries and the United States," says Mr. Volker. They are talking to their own public."

"This could lead to the unfortunate situation where Europe blames the U.S. for failure to act," adds Scott Barrett, a professor of natural-resource economics at Columbia University in New York. "It's unhelpful for countries to point to one another and say this country is doing well and this one is not."

Yet it appears as if the finger-pointing has already begun. At the U.N. meeting in Barcelona Monday, Yvo de Boer, executive secretary for the U.N. Framework Convention on Climate Change, said Copenhagen will fail without firm commitments on emission reductions from the United States.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel spoke to the U.S. Congress on Tuesday and urged the U.S. to make a firm commitment at Copenhagen. "Once we in Europe and America show ourselves ready to adopt binding agreements," she said, "we will also be able to persuade China and India to join."

U.S. negotiators have already made clear the U.S. will not commit to reductions until Congress acts on legislation before the Dec. 7 conference - something that appears increasingly unlikely.

Without commitment from the United States, it is highly doubtful that China will firmly commit to reductions.

 
Have Your Say :

We welcome your comments on this and other stories. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name and suburb/location. We also require a working e-mail address – not for publication, but for verification only.

 
Post your feedback
 
 
 
More WORLD News Stories
Dog sleds, raw seal meat and biting cold await G-7 finance ministers   2010-02-05
Toyota says Prius had brake design problems   2010-02-05
Haiti business community seeks to help rebuild economy   2010-02-05
As Toyota troubles mount, Congress wants answers   2010-02-05
Google, U.S. intel to team up to fight cyberattacks   2010-02-05
Deutsche Bank bounces back with strong 2009 profit   2010-02-05
U.S. stocks take breather after two-day rally   2010-02-05
U.S. dollar little changed in Asia   2010-02-05
Asian stocks drop after Wall Street resumes slide   2010-02-05
Oil prices down in Asian trade, stay above US$76   2010-02-05
Child slavery in Haiti is common and legal   2010-02-05
Sri Lanka leader says Tamils should work with gov't   2010-02-05
Pandas leave U.S. for new homes in China   2010-02-05
Talks unlikely   2010-02-05
Cambodia to draft new law against acid attacks   2010-02-05
Oil discovery   2010-02-05
Obama's aunt readies fresh fight   2010-02-05
Speedy vehicle plows into Nevada casino; 2 dead, 8 hurt   2010-02-05
Suns end Nuggets hot home form   2010-02-05
Milito gives Inter slight advantage   2010-02-05
 
01     02   03   04   05   06   07   08   09   Next   >
 
To search for articles form the past seven days, Click on ARCHIVES
  7day free
 
 
TOP

©2009 Taiwan News All Rights Reserved.