The White House and Senate Democrats have turned to a proposal to tax breast implants, tummy"> Plastic surgery levy to help US health care plan - Taiwan News Online
 
News Photos
Search Advanced Sign in / Register fans
 
WORLD NEWS    
 

Advertisement

Plastic surgery levy to help US health care plan
By JULIE HIRSCHFELD DAVIS
Associated Press
2009-11-20 07:26 AM
They call it the "Botax."

The White House and Senate Democrats have turned to a proposal to tax breast implants, tummy tucks, wrinkle-smoothing injections and other procedures as they search for ways to pay for costly health care overhaul plans.

President Barack Obama campaigned on a promise of offering affordable health care to all Americans, but the recession and a deepening budget deficit have made it difficult to win support for costly new programs. Vanity was an easy target as lawmakers scraped for cash for the nearly $1 trillion plan.

Skin-smoothing Botox injections could be hard-hit. There were some 4.7 million last year at an average cost per visit of about $400, some including several injections.

It's no joke to the drug makers and people who perform cosmetic nips and tucks _ and they're fighting back.

"It is a random hit on an easy target that is only punitive and not corrective," said Caroline Van Hove, a spokeswoman for Allergan Inc., the maker of Botox Cosmetic. "The bottom line is that taxing cosmetic procedures is unnecessarily punitive on people who have merely decided to enhance their appearance."

The United States is the only developed nation that does not have a comprehensive national health care plan for all its citizens and about 50 million of America's 300 million people lack health insurance. Obama says that overhauling health care is vital to the U.S.'s long-term economic recovery.

The "Botax" proposal in the 10-year, nearly $1 trillion health care draft unveiled by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid would slap a 5 percent excise tax on elective cosmetic surgeries and procedures. The plan, projected to raise $6 billion, wouldn't apply to surgery to fix a deformity or injury, but would include procedures such as face lifts, liposuction, cosmetic implants or teeth-whitening.

The plastic surgeons may have seemed like an appealing bunch to pick on given that they had already been skeptical of the Democrats' overhaul proposal. But they say it will be a blow to countless American women _ of every income level.

"The common misconception is that this is going to tax wealthy, suburban Republican women," said Dr. Phil Haeck the president-elect of the American Society of Plastic Surgeons. In fact, he said, of the 86 percent of cosmetic surgery patients who are female, 60 percent of them have incomes between $30,000 and $90,000.

In addition, he said the tax would be especially hurtful in tough economic times that have prompted many newly jobless women to look for ways to make themselves more marketable to prospective employers.

"They're competing with people 10 to 15 years younger than them and they want to look better," he said.

Accounts vary on who first dreamed up the Botax. It came out of a late-July meeting on health care that included Sen. Max Baucus, the Finance Committee chairman, and Peter Orszag, Obama's budget director, although neither man's staff acknowledges having hatched the scheme.

In the end, Reid revived it simply because "we needed money to make the bill work," his spokesman Jim Manley said.

The emergence of the tax in the latest Senate health legislation shows what can happen when an industry or company that's in Congress' cross-hairs isn't vigilant enough.

Dr. Daniel Russo plastic surgeon who heads the American Academy of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, said his group first heard of the cosmetic procedure tax idea over the summer. But after being assured by several lawmakers and senior congressional aides that it was not being seriously considered, the group opted not to engage in a major lobbying battle against it, he said.

"On multiple fronts, we were assured that this was not something that any one of the senators or representatives wanted to pursue. This is something that we did not foresee," Russo said in an interview.

"We feel it's unfair to those people who've saved hard-earned moneys to have something to improve their appearance, and now may not even be able to afford it."

 
Have Your Say :

We welcome your comments on this and other stories. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name and suburb/location. We also require a working e-mail address – not for publication, but for verification only.

 
Post your feedback
 
 
 
More WORLD News Stories
Dog sleds, raw seal meat and biting cold await G-7 finance ministers   2010-02-05
Toyota says Prius had brake design problems   2010-02-05
Haiti business community seeks to help rebuild economy   2010-02-05
As Toyota troubles mount, Congress wants answers   2010-02-05
Google, U.S. intel to team up to fight cyberattacks   2010-02-05
Deutsche Bank bounces back with strong 2009 profit   2010-02-05
U.S. stocks take breather after two-day rally   2010-02-05
U.S. dollar little changed in Asia   2010-02-05
Asian stocks drop after Wall Street resumes slide   2010-02-05
Oil prices down in Asian trade, stay above US$76   2010-02-05
Child slavery in Haiti is common and legal   2010-02-05
Sri Lanka leader says Tamils should work with gov't   2010-02-05
Pandas leave U.S. for new homes in China   2010-02-05
Talks unlikely   2010-02-05
Cambodia to draft new law against acid attacks   2010-02-05
Oil discovery   2010-02-05
Obama's aunt readies fresh fight   2010-02-05
Speedy vehicle plows into Nevada casino; 2 dead, 8 hurt   2010-02-05
Suns end Nuggets hot home form   2010-02-05
Milito gives Inter slight advantage   2010-02-05
 
01     02   03   04   05   06   07   08   09   Next   >
 
To search for articles form the past seven days, Click on ARCHIVES
  7day free
 
 
TOP

©2009 Taiwan News All Rights Reserved.