News Photos
Search Advanced Sign in / Register fans
 
POLITICS    
 

Advertisement

How the Electoral College system works
Agence France-Presse
Page 6
2008-11-03 01:13 AM
+ Enlarge This image
Traditional Russian Matryoshka dolls with pictures of U.S. Democratic presidential nominee Senator Barack Obama, left and Republican presidential nominee Senator John McCain are displayed for sale near Red Square in central Moscow, Russia yesterday.
Reuters
It's an oft overlooked fact that when Americans enter the privacy of the polling booth on Nov. 4, they will not actually be directly voting for the next president of the U.S..

Instead, in a peculiar quirk of the U.S. political system, they will choose a slate of state officials or party leaders known as electors, either Democrat or Republican, who will make up the Electoral College.

These 538 representatives will then meet in their state capitals on Dec. 15 to elect the next occupant of the White House, based on whether Democrat Barack Obama or Republican John McCain won the most votes in their states.

"To be honest I think a lot of Americans don't really understand it either," said Chris Dreibelbis, communications director at the Reform Institute, asked to explain the complex, unique American system which dates back to the 1800s.

Each of the 50 U.S. states, plus the nation's capital Washington DC, has a minimum of three Electoral College votes, but those with the largest populations have the most.

To win the Nov. 4 election, either candidate has to win 270 Electoral College votes or more. California is the largest state with 55 Electoral College votes, followed by Texas with 34.

The candidate who wins the popular vote in the state wins all its Electoral College votes, except in Maine and Nebraska, which use a tiered system.

That's why swing states such as Ohio with 20 Electoral College votes, or Pennsylvania with 21 can prove such rich pickings for candidates needing to bump up their tallies.

It's also why a candidate can win the popular vote, but lose the White House, as happened in 2000 when Democrat Al Gore lost in Florida, and its then 25 Electoral College votes tipped Republican George W. Bush to victory.

Nationally Gore had won the most popular votes taking some 50,996,582 compared with Bush on 50,456,062, but with Florida in his pocket Bush got 271 Electoral votes compared to 266 for Gore.

The Electoral College was established by the founding fathers and has been around in some form since the early 1800s when vast distances and a lack of communications meant organizing and counting a national popular vote posed immense hurdles.

"I think it was felt that creating this Electoral College would simplify the process and ensure that there was indeed a clear winner," said Dreibelbis.

Critics say the Electoral College is not always reflective of the national will, and allows candidates to focus on a handful of key swing states instead of running a truly national campaign.

Supporters however argue that changing the system to a direct vote for the president would concentrate too much power in the hands of urban populations to the detriment of rural, more sparsely populated states.

Over the past two centuries, hundreds of motions have been brought before U.S. lawmakers to either reform or abolish the Electoral College. But none has attracted enough support.

"Honestly, I have to say from my perspective there has been largely ambivalence towards it. Here in Washington I'm not seeing any big calls for abolishing the Electoral College," said Dreibelbis.

"Who knows? That may change after this election, if you have a situation where one candidate gets the majority of the popular vote and another wins the Electoral College. We had that in 2000. So if that becomes a trend I probably would say there would be a growing chorus to revisit the Electoral College."

In the event of the tie, where each candidate won 269 electoral votes, then the House of Representatives would be called on to choose the president, with lawmakers voting by state delegations.

But there is one situation where the rules remain unclear, and which has never been tested. What would happen if the winner of the Nov. 4 election were to die before the Electoral College meets in mid-December to make its choice?

Once the Electoral College meets, if anything were to happen to the president-elect before the January inauguration, then the vice president elect would step into his shoes.

 
Have Your Say :

We welcome your comments on this and other stories. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name and suburb/location. We also require a working e-mail address – not for publication, but for verification only.

 
Post your feedback
 
 
 
More Stories
White House mocks former Republican nominee   2010-02-10
Greece vows pension, tax reform as strike looms   2010-02-10
Paulson says US may profit from bank bailout   2010-02-10
US auto insurer says it warned on Toyota in 2007   2010-02-10
Argentina's Kirchner leaves ICU after surgery   2010-02-10
Ivory Coast opposition protests voter list probe   2010-02-10
Nigeria: Vice president empowered by lawmakers   2010-02-10
U.S. Marines gear up for major Afghan assault   2010-02-10
First lady begins fight against childhood obesity   2010-02-10
Republicans wary of pitfalls in bipartisan health care summit   2010-02-10
DPP insists on legislative taskforce to supervise ECFA   2010-02-10
ECFA with China will help Taiwanese do business: President Ma   2010-02-10
Su could win Taipei City mayoral election: poll   2010-02-10
Iran to stop higher level enrichment if given nuclear fuel   2010-02-10
Field training for Hankuang war games slated for late April: MND   2010-02-09
Sri Lanka's president dissolves parliament   2010-02-09
Tymoshenko camp vows to challenge Ukraine vote   2010-02-09
Europe searches for way out of debt crisis   2010-02-09
Greece vows pension, wage reform as strike looms   2010-02-09
Taiwan has no deadline for cross-strait trade pact: president   2010-02-09
 
01     02   03   04   05   06   07   08   09   Next   >
 
To search for articles form the past seven days, Click on ARCHIVES
  7day free
 
 
TOP

©2009 Taiwan News All Rights Reserved.